10/15 - While standing in line for Bela Tarr's new feature
The Turin Horse on Saturday afternoon, one of the festival programmers made his way up and down the line in an attempt to save anyone from being late for a later screening, announcing that the
The Turin Horse has had 20 minutes added to it. I knew I was in line with some real film buffs when one of them said "that's nothing for a Tarr movie," and my response--"that's two shots!"--got a laugh, my partner Jen rolling her eyes at our collective film geek-ery. So, with the running time now set at 156 minutes, we entered the cinema showing the new Bela Tarr picture. If you have no experience with Tarr, it is important to know that to a good majority of the movie-going public, Tarr's movies would probably appear as the perfect, grueling example of artsy-fartsy, intolerably slow, black and white European cinema. For myself and fans of Tarr's endurance test cinema, it is a rare opportunity to utilize the cinema in all of it's meditative and philosophical capacities, picking up in Hungarian where the great Russian master
Tarkovsky left off.
Andrei Tarkovsky's Stalker
 |
| Bela Tarr's The Turin Horse |
The Turin Horse does not disappoint as a new addition to Tarr's few-and-far-between filmography. I tend to be a bit of a purist when it comes to cinema events like a new Tarr picture. Although it's great to see great films any way you can get them, some pictures are just built for the collective theater experience. Some of my favorite pictures this year have been those that turn the wide screen cinema into church, particularly Malick's
The Tree of Life, and now
The Turin Horse, neither of which I would imagine lend themselves well to the at-home rental experience.
 |
| Terrance Malick's The Tree of Life |
 |
| Bela Tarr's The Turin Horse |
I can still recall the slight air of absurdity in attending my first Tarr picture, a screening of
Satantango at
Facets Cinemateque about 8 or 9 years ago that I was invited to by my friend, and equally adventurous movie goer, Nathaniel Carlson (check out his excellent film writing at
Cineaste online). 7 and 1/2 hours? Two intermissions? Black and white? Hungarian? I was probably a bit skeptical, but Nathaniel knew I was someone who is always up for a challenging experience at the movies, and I trust Nathaniel because he's the only person I know who can hold film makers like Bela Tarr and
Zalman King in the same intellectual head-space.
 |
| Zalman King's Lake Consequence |
 |
| Bela Tarr's The Turin Horse |
And, yes, I do think that seeing
Satantango significantly changed the way I watch movies...for the better, that is. It certainly changed the vision of more than a few film makers,
Gus Van Sant primary among them, as evidenced in his "Tarr trilogy" of
Gerry (2002),
Elephant (2003), and
Last Days (2005). Tarr is looking to hold all that is holy about cinema in his films, with the greatest stress being placed on the image. And Tarr's images are worth spending time with, as small details shift and become endowed with a great weight.
 |
| Gus Van Sant's Gerry |
 |
| Bela Tarr's The Turin Horse |
Yesterday at the festival I was trying to defend
The Turin Horse to two long time CIFF attendees as we stood in line for the new Wim Wenders film. The delightful and intelligent couple had given up on
The Turin Horse before it's grim finale, and even though I understood that they had no idea what they were getting into, my defense of the film was that most commercial films don't even have images worth remembering, but Tarr is unique in that you can nearly hold the entire picture in your mind (whether you wish to or not, I guess).
The Turin Horse is ultimately less elaborate than either
Satantango (1994)
or
Werckmeister Harmonies (2000) in it's narrative, but in it's attempt to follow the path of the animal whose torture apparently drove the great existentialist philosopher Nietzsche to the point of collapse, it succeeds as a meditative elaboration on the cruelty of existence, as well as the humor of futility. Although there were a few (sometimes unsure) laughs at the Saturday screening of
The Turin Horse, I think that the humor in Tarr is often overlooked. Tarr inexplicably mines moments of humor from the desolate, wind-swept isolation of a father and daughter trapped in a circular cycle of dependence and subsistence. Tarr really emphasizes the technique of repetition in his "Six Day" structure, and even though we are looking at the same routines, we are always seeing them from a different angle. An extra belt of alcohol, or a slightly shifted placement of a glass--the nuance of day to day change--play against the constant, doom laden erosion of the relentless wind that pervades the film. Admittedly, Tarr is not for everyone. But opening yourself up to the possibilities of a Bela Tarr film, even once, has the potential for significant change.
Up Next: Xan Aranda's new documentary rocks:
Andrew Bird: Fever Year